What an epic disappointment.
Here is a LINK to some comments, on Amazon, that share my sentiment.
Gone Girl, written by Gillian Flynn, was recommended to me by a friend who had mentioned the ending being ‘different’ - I should have asked for clarification. My bad!
The book is divided into three parts.
The first third is very intriguing… you flip through the pages wondering what’s up. Your curiosity is piqued.
The middle third gets way too convoluted with too many unlikely things pretending to be likely to happen in the real world… but, you still turn the pages.
Then comes the last third… what was Ms. Flynn thinking? Did her brain just shut down? Was she caught in some overly long ‘gone blank’ moment where only drivel trickled down to fingers patiently hovering over waiting keypads?
I want to know...
What could be Ms. Flynn’s justification for this weak, third rate ending?
I’d like to know because I am TOTALLY PISSED, TICKED and RIGHT ROYALLY ANNOYED with her lame-assed ending.
I (along with many others) was gripped at the onset and eagerly turned pages in anticipation. I wondered. I hummed and hawed at the twists - some less believable as I imagined myself in the role of Amy. I jumped into Nick’s shoes and saw what a weak man he was, but hey, okay, I still flipped pages.
Then, as I round the corner on second, I trip over a whole bunch of filler; silly stuff, pointless stuff, not believable stuff, and think, hmm, has Ms. Flynn stepped out of her writing cave (accessible only through an unfinished basement) and lost her train of thought - you know, the thought she might have had - the one the rest of us disappointed readers had - the thought whereby justice is served heavy on our plates with excess gravy and two (not one) dinner rolls to sop up the mess.
NO - we don’t get what should be our due - we get sloppy, burned leftovers - and no buns - no gravy - not even on a real plate… a true copout if ever I read one.
Did Ms. Flynn lose her nerve when debating having Amy (the proverbial bitch) terminated? How about having Nick suffer for his stupidity of staying with Amy - any thoughts occur to Ms. Flynn there? Oh, and while I’m at it, what about Amy’s parents - no consequence for them either - a slice of humble pie maybe?
Ms. Flynn had me thinking her writing was the best thing since sliced bread.
Gone Girl pretended to be a thick slab of heavy duty multigrain that required serious chewing. What Ms. Flynn gave me was fluffy white bread which was left on the counter to go stale.
Gone Girl - that’s what Ms. Flynn is - GONE from my reading list - no second slice for me.
Did Ms. Flynn really think readers would buy that weak, sickly, pathetic ending?
And… here’s the important question - where was Ms. Flynn’s “team” on this point? You can’t tell me that NO ONE mentioned to her how pathetically lame this ending was/is.
Ms. Flynn needs a new team if this is what they think passes for a great and climatic ending; limp Nick comes to mind.
Here’s the thing…
Ms. Flynn strings the reader along, we go willingly because she is a master weaver of rose-smelling bullshit. However, when it comes to delivering the goods the well dries up and all that’s left are angry flies swarming the spot where she should have dumped a stinkin’ corpse.
Gillian Flynn should be ashamed of the ending for Gone Girl.
First, because there’s nothing ‘gone’ about the ‘girl’ and second because this ending belies the great writer she’s touted to be.
No matter how you slice it a justified killing was in order.
Let me say this...
For those that rant and rave about this book - it is not a requirement to kill off a bad person, or to end a book to please me - I get that.
However, to let Amy (the bitch) off without so much as a slap on the wrist is inexcusable and lame. It just is.
Nick should have had his balls served to him for dinner (no buns or gravy). He was written to be liked initially, but there was nothing endearing about him - ever.
And, how about Amy’s ridiculous parents - who are they even fashioned after? They truly deserved a good beheading for just existing - seriously. They are the equivalent of broccoli from the freezer - tasteless and rubbery. Bordering on slimy actually.
Folks, life is short.
There are lots of great books to read - this is NOT one of them. Put it down NOW and move to the next one on your pile.
I wished I had.
NOW - if you really still want to read it - take it out of the library. No one should be making money off you for this kind of writing.
Have you read Gone Girl?
What’s your take…?